It’s vaguely ringing a bell. I definitely don’t think a large abundance or unlimited samples(archive) as a general rule is the right call either. I think it’s good having it as a shifting thing to the hosts discretion. I find having the host handpick and provide the samples, curating them to the theme and custom rules naturally limits them to a certain extent and if their theme is better served by having more or less samples it’s good that they have the wiggle room for that. So to put it simply, I don’t think we need to change anything regarding samples at this stage.
Here’s something else that might be cool to discuss though: In terms of having the BB’s be more welcoming or accessible versus challenging in their own particular way that demarcates it’s “unique” spin on the beat battle game , a bigger question is weather we want to keep it a strictly sampling/resampling challenge or would introducing a limited use of DAW or physical instruments might shake things up a little.
When I host, I can be loose about it sometimes, I’ve sometimes allowed an instrument to be used and I’ve allowed the use of your own voice or copyright free acappellas in the fine print of almost all of my beat battles. To my memory no one’s ever taken me up on the voice thing though lol, and also no one’s ever complained about it. Other people have sporadically allowed or required the use of specific or open instruments in their themes also and it’s usually been at least interesting. I don’t know if I mean to make a rule about any of this but I find the freedom for the host to go wild and weird if they choose to has been healthy for the BB’s and I’d like to encourage it.
Remember when it was all specific genre themes for awhile? That was equal parts inspiring and frustrating sometimes.
God, I ramble don’t I