A time before Spotify

Today I wrote a nostalgic piece about Ares, Winamp, burnt CDs and USB Mp3 players…

yuna2k-MY SONGS.mp3

Would love to read your thoughts about the subject :slight_smile:

3 Likes

Totally.

For me, I still do this kind of thing. The difference now is it’s youtube playlists. I’ve never liked spotify, but YT music is actually pretty good.

I’m also so far off the beaten path in terms of my music taste that there’s still plenty of friction. If I want lossless playback of the music that I want to hear, a lot of it is so obscure that it’s not on Spotify. So I have to track down and import used CDs

1 Like

thats so cool! so you listen to them just at home or do u have a portable CD player? I have a cassette player but i havent used it in a long time

1 Like

I rip the CDs losslessly and then listen to them mostly when I’m at home. I sold my CD player a few years ago because I pretty much only listen to music either while I work (youtube music) or when I’m in my studio (lossless CD rips). I’m actually starting to sell the CD collection too. Once I have them ripped there’s really no need to keep them, and if I can sell them for close to what I paid then I can afford to rip more CDs. It’s piracy with extra steps.

1 Like

I’ve never used Spotify or really any streaming music service. The only online streaming I’ve ever done is bandcamp and the occasional youtube. I keep my own digital copies of albums on my and can access them from anywhere. I digitized my vinyl, cassettes and CDs long ago. These days I usually just buy digital copies and download them locally, or rip whatever thing someone’s selling if a physical copy is my only option (it rarely is nowadays).

Despite growing up with big vinyl album art and fold out cassette liner notes and all that jazz, I was an early proponent of going digital and I have zero interest in physical objects related to music. “You mean I can get rid of all this shit?” was and still is my mantra.

On the other hand, I refuse to pay some third party for music I don’t actually own and can be taken away from me, or just becomes inaccessible if my internet is down. I guess I occupy a comfortable but somewhat precarious middle ground of wanting to be all digital but not wanting to rely on someone else to host it.

2 Likes

I agree it’s the way to go. I am still planning on building myself a media server for music/movies so that I can just listen from whatever PC I’m at instead of having to be in my studio environment. But I’m pretty happy with things as they are now too.

1 Like

Provided Spotify stays relatively decent, I really do prefer streaming over digging out CDs (or, god forbid, tapes), ripping them, cataloging and tagging them, putting them on my phone so I can listen on the go, etc. Even the nostalgic version sucked; listening at home was the only option, and if some rare shit got scratched, that was the end of it.

I’ve mentioned this before, but with digital releases in mind, if streaming ever goes down the tubes as a whole (as unlikely as it is), we’re bound to lose a lot of music that never even had a physical release in the first place, and that really makes the territory even stranger. If every release was available elsewhere and I could justify spending the monthly fee of streaming on whatever album I’m currently fixated on, I absolutely would, but we just don’t live in that world anymore.

Bandcamp is a great alternative to just streaming, but I certainly can’t afford to support all the artists that I’d like to. And even in that case, not every artist or label who uses Spotify uses Bandcamp as an alternative, so there’s still a lot missing there.

I’m not sure what the best way to (ethically) reproduce the effect of owning media in a digital age really consists of, but it seems like the only option of listening to newer music is to just stream it from somewhere, since that’s what we’ve all kind of settled on.

1 Like

There is also a lot of music that isn’t on Spotify cause not all people can afford to pay the fees. I have friends from poorer places that basically upload to Youtube or Soundcloud. Mostly Youtube. Also I know that went full “anti-system” and eliminated all music from all platforms and it just exists in physical records (CDs and cassettes). For me it just feel pretentious, but that approach exists.

For once, I am entirely at the opposite end of your POV :thinking:

If I had room and money, my physical collection would be huge. It’s rather evident to me now that I’ll never own a house that would have a basement I could make my listening place and my studio. Or if that happens, I’ll be in my late 60’s and back in France… Sad, but life happens and all that.

I have probably 2,000+ records: vinyl, CDs, tapes (and even some minidiscs if I count my old live recordings of random gigs I went to). While I have been selling more and more records lately, I still happily buy some. I LOVE records. It would make me very sad to only own digital stuff.

All those objects and sometimes little art pieces are not just “stuff”. They are an extension of my memory, and therefore, rather invaluable to me.

I can take any old CD or 7" from my collection and pieces of my past pop up in my head, because I keep what’s been important to me at a point in time in my life. Similarly, I have gotten rid of albums that made me sad, because they took me back to years of my life I have very little interest in remembering.

I use digital via Bandcamp usually and I watch the odd YT videos, but that’s about it.

2 Likes

the main reason i switched from digital to (mostly) physical media is so i can more greatly appreciate the albums i really like/love. it’s a lot different pulling out my copy of Devourment - Molesting the Decapitated, reading the lyrics, the liner notes, and the photos than just going to Pulser on my phone and hitting play on the first track.

its also essential to have a cd or tape player to check out any new harsh noise releases. its so obscure and underground that the only consistent way i’ve found for finding new releases is going to distros and filter by this year. of course, approaches like this lead to the backlog problem, which does not pair well with my habit of procrastination.

i also find cassettes to be really cool, and my preferred method of listening for most genres. but anything with too electronic of an influence, then it being on an analog format doesn’t seem right to me. then i’ll pick it up on CD. i hope to have a small but curated music collection like the one I have now.

2 Likes

So yeah while I am growing evermore hateful of the corporate bullshit of music streaming apps, I am all for the concept of all music being readily available. i also love MY music being available. there are so many problems with our current listening landscape, where we’re at right now with the internet and where it’s all headed kinda caves me in, so much so that over the past few years I have felt very detached from music as a whole. starting Tape Loops reignited my love for music again. I rediscovered my interest in cassette tapes completely changed my outlook on life and this journey continues to do so for me. doesn’t mean I don’t enjoy streaming music but tapes are different.

2 Likes

That’s why I still use an ipod. I spent five hours tonight gathering some new music and putting it on there (just found out Thom Yorke has a kid who makes music??), so I will appreciate it all the more. Way more fun than looking it up on Spotify.

Also one less thing I’m not using my fucking phone for.

I’m also aware that I’m completely out of touch lol. That’s fine.

1 Like

Well Djs still have to do a similar thing, so you arent that much out of touch :wink: haha

1 Like

This is definitely true, too. I always figured anyone could get one of those ‘label’ packages and upload whatever they want for a pretty flat yearly fee, but it definitely depends on where you live and if it’s even worth sinking the $20 or whatever it costs into.

There are a lot of indie artists who I feel like would benefit from being on Spotify, but there’s no way I’d ever know if they gave it a few-year-run and just bottomed out at zero listeners (I’ve done it myself, actually). It’s a tough game, and it’s not always worth playing when everything’s running on clout and pay-to-win style playlists and ‘curators’.

Bandcamp usually saves the day in those instances, for sure.