I once copied drum patterns from Godflesh. I mean that was more or less intentional, as in terms of drum programming this is my biggest inspiration, but I copied a piece of "Regulator" by Devin Townsend and that was surprising.
Even if it does trigger some memory of a song that exists...what is the purpose of this thread? What are you asking? Or are you asking anything? That's what I don't get about many of your threads. It seems like you say "This happens? Discuss." I'm just wondering if it's a roll-call thread again where people say yes or no and that's pretty much the info we get out if. My answer would be yes (of course). What else there is to say about it, I have not figured out quite yet.
Yes another post where I come off as slagging the OP. But really, Maybe I'm just not understanding why these threads exist, because as clever as it may be to some of you, I can't see the cleverness here. Is it an agreement thread? Yes I agree, then. But my question is, what do we get out of it other than the agreement? That one guy who doesn't have this issue? He's not here yet, apparently. BTW, I'm not trying to start an argument with anybody. But can someone at least see my point?
have to agree with you there, but here it's more like "does this happen to anyone else?"
It's actually kind of curious. I remember coming up with this melody while playing the sax over a basic chord progression, and it felt way too "perfect" to be mine. So I was pretty much convinced that I had subconsciously gotten it from somewhere else since this kind of thing happens so often to me. Turns out it actually was mine, or at least I never found the original song if it ever existed (but i doubt it).
I just think its annoying that you or I at least start a riff or melody with a few notes then as I rack my brain or just play away to come up with something it auto starts playing already known melodies with similar start.
Maybe its not a question but an interesting discussion but hey if anyone reading dont wanna discuss this topic you know what you can do
This happens to me a lot. What's really frustrating is when whatever you wrote sounds familiar, but you cannot identify what it sounds like, and neither can your friends, but they agree it sounds familiar. Then you have to decide for yourself if you are imagining things and should keep going, or should try something else.
I once played a C note and it instantly reminded of 17,346 pop songs.
Is it really accidental is what I want to ask. We are fine tuned to always look for patterns, and we not are always aware we are doing it. In that light what we play will be influenced by the things we listen to. It's not rocket science.
Sometimes I PURPOSEFULLY steal something I find inspiring to get me started on a new tune. I may use the key it is in, or the chords and then I make it mine.
If you have a good ear and a decent memory it can really annoy YOU! I made a melody the other day and i thought it sounded familiar so I ended up rummaging through some Star Trek Movies to find the similar melody. Luckily it only had a few similar intervals but not as close as I was afraid of. I wonder sometimes as well if playing all those 8-bit games as a kid kinda fried my melodic brain. Gasp! Maybe subconsciously I am simply writing down my music memories as a kid?!
This happens all the time. I don't think there are many melodies/chord progressions within our western music system that haven't been played at some point during the relatively long history of western music.
In my opinion you should stop worrying and overthinking so much (after reading through some of the threads you recently started) and just make music... You are at a point where your goal should simply be getting better so it shouldn't matter if the melody you found is similar or the same as another one... And even if it's the same meldoy you could still arrange it differently and make it a completely new song