IDMf - Electronic Music & Production Forum -

IDMf - Electronic Music & Production Forum - (
-   Hardware and Gear (
-   -   Korg R3 vs Miniak (

oDDgOD 16-06-2017 09:45 PM

Korg R3 vs Miniak
Im looking for a synth under $300 and my research points to the the MiniAK or the R3 as being close to what I want. I'm looking to get more into creating my own patches/editing presets and depending less on stock presets (though I'm not against using them). I also use step sequencing a lot, so I need a synth with a decent sequencer.

As I understand the MiniAK is a pain to edit and the vocoder isn't as good as the R3 but it sounds better. I'm not a huge fan of the Korg sound but I can work with it. I did like what I've heard of the miniak. Both have sequencers.

Anyone here have any experience with or a preference of the 2?
Are there other options I'm overlooking that would be a good fit?

jbvdb493 16-06-2017 10:19 PM

Re: Korg R3 vs Miniak
No opinions on either, but I am curious why the need for a sequencer?
As opposed to using one you might already have?

oDDgOD 19-06-2017 06:51 PM

Re: Korg R3 vs Miniak

Originally Posted by jbvdb493 (Post 1449117)
No opinions on either, but I am curious why the need for a sequencer?
As opposed to using one you might already have?

I prefer to be able to compose on a piece of gear without needing other pieces. But I think, due to finances, I might finally start using some of the many free VSTs out there and just get a decent midi controller, (looking at the maudio axiom 25) while sticking with the qy-70 as my sketchpad/sequencer.

It wont have the portability I want, and I try to stay as out of the box as possible, but in the long run the music will benefit more.

relic 19-06-2017 10:02 PM

Re: Korg R3 vs Miniak
Have you thought about the Korg Monologue? Dunno if you are looking for polyphony, but it sounds pretty damn good plus a step sequencer that allows knob movement recording : ) I really don't know either of those synths at all so... can't make a good alternative suggestion.

If you don't mind digital and want polyphony you might be able to get a Novation MiniNova for a decent price, not quite as nice to program as its big brother (UltraNova) but has some cool perfomance tricks up its sleeves.

Geeogi 29-06-2017 04:52 PM

Re: Korg R3 vs Miniak
i have experience only with the R3.

I find it very easy to use, and particularly easy to modify patches etc. The options for modifying are great too –I've always been able to modify the things i needed. Particularly with their step sequencer function which allows you to mod parameters using a recorded sequence of automation.

The r3 has a great sound. It sounds like a synth, not like a computer (a good thing). Though I don't find the sound quite as compelling as the Roland Gaia –that is a super fun synth.

The vocoder is great and super handy that the r3 comes with a goose neck microphone. Much easier to use than a mic stand etc.

On reflection, I would have bought a synth that has more knobs and buttons i.e. gaia or radias. With soft synths sounding better and better, the main factor which attracts me to using a synth is the fun factor of messing with the buttons.

Oldskooltekno 11-08-2017 01:07 AM

Re: Korg R3 vs Miniak
the Arturia Microbrute Analog Synthesizer sells for 300
has a step sequencer and has a lot of sound making shaping capabilities

the only thing is the keyboard is kind of small so only pretty much one octave .

beautifulhurl 11-08-2017 04:35 AM

Re: Korg R3 vs Miniak
The Miniak is pretty strong, it has the same engine as the Alesis Micron. I ended up selling it because it felt like I was diving through menus too often, and it ended up being a bit too heavy for my rig at the time, as it was surprisingly heavy. That said, it can do a lot, and it has some interesting filters, so you could find it perfect for a lot of different purposes.

All times are GMT +1. The time now is 02:33 AM.

Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.8.7
Copyright ©2000 - 2018, vBulletin Solutions, Inc.